The Philosopher king is no addition or insertion, but the logical outcome of insertion of Plato's Principles (Barker). Critically examine.
Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025
Emerson held that 'Plato is philosophy and Philosophy is Plato'. Regarded as the father of Political Philosophy, Plato's theory of philosopher king is one of his greatest & novel contribution.
Plato while giving his theory of justice, explaining that only that society is just, where people do the tasks they are naturally suited at and do not interfere in the tasks of others. Men of Reason should be the rulers, Men of courage should be the protectors and men of passion should be the producers.
To filter out men of different qualities, Plato devises a system of education which is very elaborate. Only those who pass the filtration tests at ages 18 and 20 could move further to study subjects like logic, philosophy. From ages 20 to 35, men would be taught these subjects followed by 15 years of practical training. Only those who emerge successful at the age of 50, would be the rulers, i.e the Philosopher king.
Thus, it is evident that philosopher king is the logical outcome of his theories of education and justice. Plato held that, a philosopher king would be reluctant to rule and he would have to sacrifice his love for knowledge for the service of nation. Thus philosopher king is a symbol of knowledge & sacrifice.
Plato's Philosopher king is however utopian. Even his great critic and disciple, Aristotle criticizes Plato and wants the 'rule of law' over philosopher king. Karl Popper calls Plato as an enemy of open society as the Philosopher king becomes the basis for totalitarianism. However, although utopian, one has to give due credit to Plato for showing what ought to be.