Critically assess whether the current model of Panchayati Raj in India is compatible with the principle of participatory democracy or has it devolved into a mechanism of mere formal decentralisation?
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
As per Ashok Mehta Committee, Panchayati Raj sowed the seeds of democracy in Rural soils that cultivated development psyche in India.
Through 73rd Amendment decentralized democracy in rural India promoted the principle of Subsidiarity (2nd ARC).
As per polycentric model of Governance by Elinor Ostrom, communities are better manager of 7 aspects - for ex, Ibrahimpur village panchayat achieved 0% mortality and 100% sanitation (SDG with local Governance).
Further, the reservation of marginalised empowered the lower sections. As per Esther Duflo Report, women sarpanchs promoted socio-economic development more than their male counterparts. For instance Sushma Badu, Sarpanch fought against female infanticide. Fathima Bi of Andhra got UNDP award for poverty eradication.
Nevertheless, there are issues in 3Fs - funds, function & functionaries. As per MoPR, only 10% funds are from own-budget of Panchayats. Also, there are quotas without capacity development and cultural shifts that promotes Sarpanch Pati Syndrome.
Mani Shankar Aiyar Committee held that it promoted decentralisation of corruption.
2nd ARC suggested Activity Mapping and specialised Panchayat for tax buoyancy, model (Wind Power Independence) can be promoted. PM Mahila Shaktikaran yojana along with public oath hearing of women Sarpanch is needed. It will promote Gram Uday Se Bharat Uday