Topper Copies

The evolution of Fundamental Rights jurisprudence in India reflects a shift from a textual to a purposive interpretation. Discuss this transformation with reference to landmark Supreme Court judgements.

Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025

Fundamental Rights under Part-III of Indian Constitution have been guarded by Supreme Court via Article 32 and its original jurisdiction.

Before emergency of 1975 fundamental Rights jurisprudence was mostly textual. Being justiciable rights, SC promoted fundamental Rights above DPSPs becoming barrier in land reforms; socio-economic justice.

for instance, in Champakam Dorairajan Case, SC held that FRs cannot be violated for DPSP implementation. It leads to Amendment zeal of parliament that transformed by FRs through amendment while 1st Amendment - The introduction of Ninth Schedule reduced the scope of judicial review.

The textual approach was restrictive and non - visionary as Golaknath Judgement termed FRs as sacrosanct that shifted the possibility of implementation of public - spirited DPSPs.

Moreover, during emergency (1975), In A.D.M. Jabalpur case, Supreme Court narrowed the scope of Habeus corpus. It shattered the vision of Indian Constitution that J.L. Nehru observed - does not anticipated passive judiciary.

There emerged shift in jurisprudence post - emergency era where Supreme Court started metaphysical & innovative interpretations of the Constitution.

In 1976 of Keshavananda Bharati case, SC introduced Basic Structure Doctrine to ensure preservation of Constitutional supremacy over Parliamentary sovereignty.

In Maneka Gandhi case (1977), the scope of Article 21 was expanded for Due process of law over narrow procedure established by law.

The PIL movement in 1980s by Justice Iyer promoted relaxation of locus-standi to promote justice at the door-steps of disadvantaged.

In Bandhu Mukti Morcha - Article 21 was expanded as dignity concerns exploitation.

It also unlocked social order in Sabrimala judgement and Triple Talaq case by equality rights (Article 14, 21).

further Puttaswamy judgement (Right to Privacy) and Navtej Singh Johar case (decriminalising homosexuality) expanded the scope of Article 21 for post-material human dignity.