Comment on the following in about 150 words each: Role of the GST council in Fiscal Federalism.
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
GST council is a constitutional architecture under Article 279 A to promote fiscal cooperative federalism. It was established via 101st constitutional Amendment.
It enables the platform for deliberative and participative federalism where states have more weightage of vote (2/3rd) than Centre. It promotes Public Choice model of James Buchanan for state flexible autonomy.
Further, GST council enables dispute resolution on issues such as tax rates, cesses and surcharges. This model has empowered fiscal health of states with above 1 crore tax revenue becoming new normal.
However, there are limitations in GST council on resolving issues such as compensation cess dispute or diverting GST to petroleum, crude oil product.
Due to rigid structure, GST has failed to promote fiscal consensus on various issues. Pratap Bhanu Mehta argues role of power, party and economic inequality amongst states as hindering holding-together spirit.
There is need of more institutionalization of fiscal federalism under GST for fiscal collaborative and centrifugal federalism model.