Comment on the following in about 150 words each: Different perspectives on the Revolt of 1857
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
Revolt of 1857 was the major revolt involving diverse grievances of Indians from the alien rule of merchant turned into colonial rule of East India Company.
Colonialists such as Seeley and Strachey narrated the description as mere Sepoy mutiny to delegitimise the cries of dismantling the colonial rule.
Eric Stokes presented the revolt as Barbaric ruling the White man's burden hegemony.
further, Ostrom termed it as Mohammadan conspiracy which led to seeded the policy of divide & rule of colonials.
But V.D. Savarkar analyzed the Revolt as first war of Independence. It was more than a sepoy mutiny because every sepoy was peasant in uniform. The involvement of kings, queens, zamindars (e.g. Rani Laxmibai, Tantia Tope) demonstrated the wide movement.
In 'Asbab - e - Bhagwat - e Hind', Sir Syed Ahmed Khan countered the Mohammadans conspiracy theory on analysing the fallacies of British rule which fuelled discontent (e.g. exorbitant rate of revenue).
further, R.C. Majumdar held that 'It was neither a sepoy mutiny nor first war of independence due to limited reach and lack of participation of major sections (e.g.- Sikh, Maratha).
But 1857 Revolt became an inspiration for National consciousness against British Rule.