Distinguish between social equality, political equality, and economic equality. To what extent can they be realised independently?
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
Ronald Dworkin famously quoted Equality as Sovereign virtue because when humans are treated equally; it unlocks the potential of creative freedom and social cohesion.
The different spheres of Equality are - political, social and economic. Political Equality refers to equal citizenship; one vote, one man, one value and equal access to political offices and resources. Though Aristotle promoted political inequality b/w amongst greek, non-greek and male-female; but classical liberals promoted political equality such as in Two Treatises of Representative Government by Locke.
Socially, Equality refers to equal dignity of all and it requires affirmative action from the state to rectify historical social injustice. It is promoted by Dr- B.R. Ambedkar and Indian Constitution (Article 15,16).
Economic equality refers to equal distribution of basic needs. socialists and Marxists argue for radical equality of outcome for common ownership of economic resources.
To realise these forms of Inequality, various models have developed. The minimal state of Advanced states such as US, Canada UK focus more on political equality and believe in market Fundamentalism for socio-economic meritocracy (from identity to development).
On the other hand, Scandinavian Countries promote welfarism as right (E. Anderson) for collective realization of social, economic and political equality.
Dr- B R- Ambedkar held that without base of socio-economic democracy, political democracy as top-soil will be realized eventually. So, all three should be realized simultaneously.
However, libertarians eg Hayek, Friedman argues that promotion of economic equality leads to inefficiency. But it also depends on the capacity & will of the state (e.g. DPSPs in India).
Normatively all three should be realized for substantive democracy.