Topper Copies

Explain the tensions between cultural relativism and the advocacy of universal human rights in global politics.

Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025

On 10 December, 1948, Universal Declaration of Human right at UN posited inalienable and irrevocable universal human rights. However, cultural relativism advocates against Human rights as hegemonic implementations.

The advocate of universal Human rights argue that there is moral unity in inherent dignity of all humans as in Kantian categorical Imperative.

further, the Bhakti and Sufi thinkers of India also established moral equality in all humans in ideas such as Ek Noor te sab jag upjaya and Wahadul - Ul - Wajud.

Cultural Relativist (Frantz Fanon) on the other hand sees the Western hegemonic implementation of Human rights in non-individualistic and communitarian Asian-African societies.

As per Asian Relativism of Mhd. Mahathir and Lee Kuan Yew there is the hidden geopolitical & exploitative intentions in Human right discourses. (for instance, regime changes in Middle East - gunpoint Human Right & democracy by US & NATO).

However, feminists like Susan Moller Okin fear that in the garb of Culturalism, there is legitimisation of inhuman female genital mutilations, cultural politics, child marriage in Afro-Asian societies.

Further, Amartya Sen and Barry Buzan lamented that Cultural Relativism sometimes leads to ghettoisation and act as impediment to the human-development further, Sen analyzed in Argumentative India how democracy & human dignity are not alien to India.

There is need of Overlapping Consensus proposed by John Rawls or Multiculturalism with Harm principle of Bhikhu Parekh to have meaningful dialogues on Human Right & Cultural Rights-

Those human rights to be promoted that do not harm social good and those cultural rights to be tolerated that do not harm individual dignity-