Topper Copies

Examine the evolution of the idea of justice from Plato to Rawls.

Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025

John Rawls in his work 'Justice as Fairness' described Justice as the first virtue of human society as truth is the first virtue of any school of thought.

Plato in his 'The republic' work promoted a grand Theory on Justice for promoting common good, social order and functional state, which was based on duties or functional specialization for efficiency. It so was quite similar to Varna Conscious Justice of Indian Dharmashastra. It emphasized more on whole than individualism.

Along with evolution of society from feudal to industrial, the concept of justice kept on evolving. The classical liberals like Locke, Adam Smith stated focusing on individualistic justice.

The minimal state of classical liberals posited true justice as absence of restrictions to the liberal endeavours of individual. It transformed Acknowledged rights (D-Hume) based on hereditary to justice based on meritocracy.

However this Meritocratic justice based on Darwinism of Herbert Spencer (Survival of the fittest) failed at recognising the social-economic barriers to equality of opportunity.

In Industrialised societies, there emerged massive economic inequality, erosion of social goods and egoistic individualism (Tyranny of Meritocracy- M. Sandel).

In this background, Marxism discourses emerged for Equality of outcome and Justice in communism.

However, Robert Hayek analyzed how equality of outcome leads to equality of poverty.

Further in Indian context, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar proposed substantive socio-economic justice based on Affirmative Action for historically underprivileged sections. His goal was to promote legal justice for social endosmosis.

Then in 1971 John Rawls presented his post - behavioural grand Theory of Justice - based on veil of ignorance. He presented three principles - (1) equal liberties, 2(a) Equality of opportunity and 2(b) Difference principle.

Rawlsian justice was based on social contract so that there is universal acceptance to this fair principles. Though Difference principle, he focuses on social good and Chain link theory.

from Plato's duty - bound to Rawlsian right - based principles, the normative debate on justice is the ever - continuing in political science.