Topper Copies

Feminists argue that the State is not gender-neutral; it actually functions as a patriarchal institution. In this context, discuss the feminist critique of the State.

Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025

Catherine MacKinnon observed that 'When I look at state, it appears male to me'. The feminist critique of the state reflects on gender-grievances from state which negates & promotes gender injustice.

The state in the feminist perspective is masculine concentration of power- These are only 13.6% women MPs in Indian parliament and 25% in World legislature (IPU).

There is radical feminist cry that 'Personal is political and political is personal' (Carole Hanisch) where in domestic spheres women suffer from marital rapes, domestic violences and power-asymmetry. To resolve these crisis, Madhu Kishwar concerns that state has only brought up bizarre pieces of legislation.

further, state recognises the violent & forced marriages as per sexual contract by Carole Pateman. The state act as neutral but this neutrality & promote crisis such as Marital Rapes.

feminists argue that state should not promote unreasonable uniform rights, rather Iris Marion Young argues for differentiated citizenship rights for women for historical gender injustices. for example; protection of women's physical bodily rights (Anti-Rape) and decisional privacy (reproductive autonomy and access aspirations).

In advanced capitalism to formals need redressal for equal pay for equal work, period poverty and women-centric policies on menstruation and maternal leaves.

Having discussed the criticism by feminist of state, it is critical to underscore the gender-centrism in This discourse. This limits the scope of gender-consensus between male, female & LGBTQ+ on participative democracy.

Despite some lacunae, the gender lens on state transformed the discourses such as humanising of Security and diversification of public institutions.