How did the behavioural and post-behavioural approaches together contribute to methodological pluralism in political science?
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
Behavioural and Post-Behavioural approaches are contemporary evolutions in Political Science post Second World War. These both prevented decline of political science from time to time.
Behavioural approach emerged in 1950s with David Easton's APSA and system analysis of political science. This revived political theory from static, monographic, speculative and eurocentric traditional approaches.
This added pluralism in political theories with study of dynamics - System theory David Easton, structural-functional - Almond & Powell and Political Culture - Almond & Verba
In addition, the interdisciplinary approaches aided study contextual-textual variations in post-colonial states. To study the unique behaviour of such societies - emerged - Political modernization of S. P. Huntington and Prismatic societies of F. W. Riggs.
Further in 1960s due to ivory tower syndrome in Behaviouralism, post-Behaviouralism emerged with credo of relevance and action. Now post-Behaviouralism started macro-analysis of Values behind empirical behaviours.
Together, both approaches enriched comprehensive analysis of political issues such as Rawlsian Contractual and distributive justice; libertarianism of Robert Nozick and communitarianism of Michael Sandel.
Using this approach, the post-colonial analysis deepened with Hamza Alavi's overdeveloped state and Benedict Anderson's Imagined Societies.
Not only empirical observation but interested search for values shaped post-behavioural comparative studies. for example, Arendt Lijphart presented how consociational democracy is well-suited for plural democracies.
Further, there is deepening of Political - Economy, Political - Sociology interdisciplinary studies for analyzing interaction in plural circumstances. For ex:- Christopher studied the relevance of caste in Indian political system.
There is emergence of Neo - Institutionalism (March & Olsen) that focus on logic of appropriateness in behaviours of political actors in the context of institutions.
Thus, both Behaviouralism and Post - Behaviouralism promotes normative inquiries with empirical methods.
Andrew Hacker so rightly argued that the political theorist is half scientist and half philosopher.