Despite its merits, should the POCSO Act be revisited to correct the existing inadequacies?
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Recently the Law Commission has rejected idea of change in POCSO Act as CJI has asked for changes due to changing societal morality.
Revisited to Correcting Inadequacies
1. Age of consent is 18 which is out of sync with global trends (From 10-16 in UK, USA, Europe) 2. (Romantic relationships) penalised (X% are such as per UNICEF) 3. Tribal customs and rituals permit early marriage thus creating challenges for them 4. High acquittal in cases and process is punishment. 5. Discretion given to child welfare Committee is high (eg Instances of corruption in discharging duty as per newspaper reports in Haryana) 6. Used by parents when wilfull elopment by daughter.
Analysis and Way Forward
1. Underage relationships should be allowed. 2. Societal change with regard to child marriage (NFHS-5 says 22%). Until then both laws are in conflict. 3. Integrate new forms of sexual violence eg Revenge Porn under Act 4. no process as punishment as lasting impact on youth
As we celebrate more than 10 years of POCSO, we should reflect on societal morality and gender justice to (SDG5) reform POCSO and make it a global best practice.