Comment on the following in about 150 words each: "Power and violence are opposites" (Hannah Arendt)
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
Hannah Arendt is American German thinker who presented unconventional perspective on power in her works - On Violence and The origins of Totalitarianism.
Arendt argues that power is the possession of group and it is constitutive in Vita Activa mode. This resonates with diffused theory of power of foucault and deliberative democracy of Habermas.
She compares this constitutive power of people in group with hierarchical violence in the realm of state- she posits state with violence can erode power such as Nazism of Hitler but cannot create power.
power as per Arendt is the creative freedom of masses in realm of public life. Violence, on the other hand is destructive Force - Coercive used in the hands of the totalitarian.
Though unconventional but her idea on power in context is inspired by empirical mob violence (e.g. Pehlu Khan) and exemplary morality of single leaders like Gandhi, Mother Teresa.
Nevertheless, Hannah Arendt's concept of constructive power v/s Destructive violence empowers the discourse against consumerism, erosion of public realm and rise of populist leaders worldwide