Topper Copies

The global human rights regime is based on strong and widely accepted principles and norms but has very weak mechanisms for international implementation. Discuss.

Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025

Michael Walzer's 'common minimal universal rights' were reverberated in the institution of Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) in 1945, in context of the excesses committed during the world wars.

The main document or magna carta of human rights is the International Bill of Human Rights, comprising:

1. UDHR 2. International Covenant on Civil & Political Rights 3. International Covenant on Economic & social Rights

Premised on Woodrow Wilson's emphasis on 'justice, peace and security', as outlined in the UN Charter, the human rights preserve human dignity and meaningful existence of the zoon politikon, via protection against persecution, right to recognition, livelihood, shelter and more.

mechanisms & their soundness

The operationalizing mechanism to human rights run on a formalized international forum and have also been the guiding light to domestic judicial ans.

The International Court of Justice at The Hague is the preserver sine qua of the same, but this has been criticized as a 'toothless tiger' by Joseph Nye, as witnessed in recent times, by its warrant issued against President Putin by Mongolia.

- The International Criminal Court, working jurisdictionally on genocide, humanitarian excesses on genocide, war, etc also faces similar criticism, called 'weak and subservient' by Mearsheimer, for him, states pursue own interests. Morgenthau denounces 'international moral law' as 'against state-centric anarchic international polity'.

Nonetheless, UDHR, celebrating its 75 years journey indicates a charter of popular legitimacy and has become a source of emancipation via direct and indirect adoption (eg Indian constitution).