Despite their differences, the liberal and realist approaches to international relations share many common assumptions. Analyse.
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
International relations underwent a crucial 'revolution' during the world war period. Woodrow Wilson's 'idealism' lay foreground for Liberal school whilist failure of 'collective security' emergence of realism.
The realist and liberal approaches are but a cornucopia of same issues, but with 'unaccounted' structural, instrumental and actor/unit level difference:
Realist school outlines 'state as rational actor' (morepowerful) which, in an anarchical order, tries maximising power for achieving extension under the Hobbesian 'anarchy problematizing' the liberal school, accepting the premise of 'anarchy' in international realism, offers on state's 'survival mode' action and 'constant state of war'?
Both the schools, additionally, capitalise on 'state' for security, authority with institutionalist tools and balance of power realism.
Structural realism and neoclassical liberalism but focus on 'structure' in international politics in entirety the 'end' place – one through creation of world government (woodrow wilson's concept of nations) and the other through like hegemony, versatile devices maximisation security and war.
Additionally, national interest' requires supreme in cooperation, security and stability of international system. when India postulates 'India First' as its strategic autonomy pole, both liberal and right discourse [illegible] it similarly.
Above commonalities, in addition to use of 'hard power' to 'achieve desired outcomes by influencing other's behaviours (Behaviour question) is fixated by both schools · Military sticks and economic carrots · make way for security national interest via security communities for liberals and hegemonic stability by Mearsheimer.
Thus, as dharmashastra of 'Vishnugupta (liberalism) and dandashastra [illegible] (realism), the two discourses overlap and criss cross but with singular end of interest securitization the mind.