Topper Copies

"The modern state is too small for big things and too big for small things" (Daniel Bell). Explain.

Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025

State, in the 'tripod' of liberal discourse and state-centrism of realist thought, lies at the foci of anarchical society - so as an enabler in former and centric actor in the latter.

The modern state, characterised by its evolution to the current 'New wars' Consensus, is but 'too small for big things' and runs deficient in ample effectuation of 'functionalist' achievement ends of 'peace and security' charted as the end of international politics (Art 1 of UN charter).

As per Waltzian understanding, however, state is but at the centre and is too big for small things'. A pluralist and constructivist diffusion of power in post-modern discourse, on other hand, reflects upon role of transnational actors as unambiguous teacher of working out 'small things'.

while liberal discourse of modern 'night-watchman state' (Nozick) limits self to cooperation for mutual benefits with emphasis on 'individual' (eg public diplomacy track), the realist paradigm assigns state as sine qua non to survival, security and 'stability'. (Morgenthau)