You are a young officer who has recently been posted as the District Magistrate in a district where power cuts are a regular phenomenon. A thermal power plant is proposed in your district, which has the potential to not only meet the energy demand of yours but also that of neigbouring districts, and also provide employment opportunities for the people of your district. However, a few people from the district are protesting against it because of the concerns of displacement and the potential pollution issue that the project may lead to. It is brought to your notice that prominent local leaders have mobilized a large crowd and are planning to march towards the Collectorate. You have also received information that the crowd may turn violent due to the presence of miscreants. In the context of this situation, address the following: (a) Identify the stakeholders and highlight the issues involved in the above case. (b) State the measures that you would take as the District Magistrate. (20)
Sudipa Dutta, AIR 41, 2025
(a) Stakeholders
1. District Magistrate (Me) 2. Staff of Collectorate 3. People of the district and adjoining district 4. Local Leaders 5. Thermal Power Plant Company 6. Media
Issues 1. Energy security of the district vs Sustainable use of resources of district 2. Public right to protest vs Peace and tranquility of society 3. Propaganda by local leaders vs Legitimate work by district officials 4. Environmental Concerns vs Larger Public Interest 5. Anthropocentrism vs Ecocentrism
(b) Options that I have
Option 1 Allow the thermal power plant to start its operations without taking public opinion into notice. Merits => Utilitarianism => Electricity problem sorted Demerits => Risk of gross violation of code of conduct => Public trust reduces in government => Not taking stakeholders into confidence.
Option 2 Meeting local Leaders and general public opinion generation Merits => Stakeholders into account => Dedication to duty => Commitment to public welfare Demerits => Time-consuming => Media sensitization of the issue => Pressure from higher rungs of administration
Option 3 Prohibiting the march to take place by engaging local police beforehand. Merits => Encroachment on people's right to protest => Autocratic step => Mistrust about police among public Demerits => May affect peace and security of the district => May also endanger the collectorate and its staff => Objection with normal work of the collectorate.
Option 4 Arranging a meeting with the local leaders and the thermal power plant Company and dissemination of information regarding the plant and its effect on general public. Merits => Public confidence in administration => Follow rules => Legal measure Demerits => Time-consuming => No result may be arrived at => No ultimate conclusion is also a outcome.
My Action I will first hand take Option 4 as my course of action but also add a few more steps such as:- 1. Engage local police office just in case there is disruption in some other section of population. 2. Inform the state government about ongoing crisis 3. Talk with Power Plant companies about their Corporate Social Responsibility 4. Talk to the general public myself digitally or through media conference and alleviate their fears about the project and tell them about the benefits such as employment, infrastructure building.
In this way I will be following: 1. Rules 2. Taking stakeholders into confidence 3. Maintaining peace 4. For long term solution engaging the State Govt.