You are the managing director of a pharmaceutical company. Your company has won a tender for supply of generic affordable medicines to the state health department. In order to win the tender, you had kept the profit margins very low. However, after winning the tender, you got a call from the Officer on Special Duty (OSD) to the Health Minister for a 2% cut in the total purchase of goods. You tried to meet the Health Minister in this respect, but he also hinted at doing the job as per the instructions of the OSD. You cannot refuse to go ahead with the tender because of the risk of losing your 5% security deposit. Further, the firm can be blacklisted for not fulfilling the obligations of the approved tender. Some of the options to deal with the situation are given below. Evaluate the merits and demerits of each of these options. (a) Follow the advice of the minister and comply with the demands of the OSD. (b) File a police complaint against the OSD for corruption. (c) Tip the media anonymously about the issue to build pressure on the concerned Minister. (d) Leave the allotted tender. Also, not limiting to the options given above, suggest the course of action you will take, giving appropriate reasons. (20)
Sudipa Dutta, AIR 41, 2025
Stakeholders 1. Managing director of Pharmaceutical Company (Me) 2. Minister of Health 3. OSD 4. General Public 5. Media
Ethical Dilemma 1. Crisis of conscience 2. Self interest vs Interest of Public 3. Losing to Corruption vs Rising above 4. Consciousness vs Denial
Given Measures
(a) Follow the advice of the minister and comply with the demands of the OSD. Merit => I will get my required remuneration though a bit less. => Avoiding conflict of administration => Not exactly aversion to duty.
Demerit => Supporting corruption => No Conscience => No Courage of Conviction
(b) File a police complaint against OSD for Corruption. Merits => Standing up to illegal activity. => Courage of Conviction => Loyalty to my duty
Demerits => Jeopardise my company => Conflict with higher rungs of government => Media sensitizing the issue therefore a threat to the ego of the Minister
(c) Tip the media anonymously about the issue to build pressure on the Minister. Merits => Standing up to illegal activity => Dedication to duty => Bringing illegal activity to the public domain.
Demerits => Jeopardise my company => Unnecessary media havoc => Going out of line only to prove my point
(d) Leave the allotted tender Merits => Easiest option => Neither conflict with ministry nor loss to company => Safe option
Demerits => Corruption will prosper as tender will go to someone else => Declining one's duty as a citizen of this country => Crisis of Conscience
My Action I will take neither of the options as my action rather will try to persuade the given Minister in listening to my concerns. Even then if he is adamant of his position I will take to option (3) however instead of going anonymous I will come out myself as this will give concrete evidence to my cause. Whatever happens I will not comply with Ministers demand as I cannot be a part of a malicious activity because my conscience will not allow me. And at last if neither of my actions bears fruit I will leave the allotted tender as the matter will be in public domain and they would themselved determine the further course of action.
Reasons of my rational action:- 1. I will first apply the core value of negotiations so that work is completed smoothly and in time bound manner. 2. I in this way will avoid crisis of conscience 3. I will also show courage of conviction 4. I will not bow down to unfair and illegal means.