Topper Copies

The Right to Information (RTI) Act is one of the most important reforms brought by the government. You have recently been transferred as the Public Information Officer (PIO) in the irrigation department of a district. While inspecting the RTI applications, you find that many of these applications relate to information on the recruitment of staff in your department. Your juniors point out that all of these have been filed by an aspiring local politician who may be trying to create an issue related to irregularities in recruitment in the department. The department fears that he is filing RTI applications for political gains in the upcoming state elections. In this context, answer the following questions: (a) Identify the stakeholders and the issues involved in the case. (b) What measures will you take to handle the situation? (20)

Sudipa Dutta, AIR 41, 2025

Stakeholders - Public Information Officer (Me) - Other Staff of that department - Local Politician - Local Community - Recruited official - Educated unemployed Persons of that region

Ethical Issues 1. Politicisation of bureaucracy 2. Political Influence 3. Maintaining Political Neutrality 4. Vested Interests of Politicians 5. Opinions getting influenced by politicised situation.

Various Options available to me

Option 1 Reply appropriately to the petitions filed.

Merit 1. Duty to public service 2. Commitment to code of conduct

Demerit 1. Political influence may increase even more 2. Not objective in approach.

Option 2 Warning to the local politician and giving him threat of action.

Merit 1. Maintaining political neutrality 2. No influence of politics in smooth functioning of governance

Demerit 1. Politician may think as threat to their authority. 2. Adverse public opinion about administration.

Option 3 Make senior officials aware of this situation and seek their opinions

Merit 1. Value experience 2. Making informed decision

Demerit 1. Time consuming 2. May not result into concrete solution

Option 4 Refuse to provide answers to the RTI application.

Merit 1. Maintaining due process of Government outside the purview of politics

Demerit 1. Not legal and not ethical 2. Evasion of duty.

My action

I will take neither of the above actions as a sole measure rather I will take a hybrid solution by:-

1. First giving appropriate information which is seeked as it is my official duty. 2. Call the politicians in question in my office and discuss my concerns with them and take help of other staff too. 3. Threat will not work as it will increase their propaganda against administration. 4. Provide full information of the duly conducted recruitment in the office to the general public to alleviate their fears and to crush the political propaganda once and for all.

Merits 1. Commitment to duty 2. Follow rules 3. Maintain political neutrality 4. Public fears sorted

Demerits 1. May still be not enough for the public to understand 2. Politician may find another cause of agitation.

Long term actions

1. Awareness campaign in the district about RTI act. 2. Involving civil society in disseminating information about penalties against frivolous RTI applications. 3. Taking volunteer groups into confidence to act as deterrent to political groups.