Topper Copies

Although utilitarianism is arguably the most reason-based approach to determining right and wrong, it has obvious limitations. Discuss. (150 words) 10

Sudipa Dutta, AIR 41, 2025

"Create all the happiness you are able to create; remove all the misery you are able to remove." - Jeremy Bentham

Utilitarianism is an ethical doctrine pioneered by Jeremy Bentham and J S Mill. Utilitarianism can be defined as the doctrine which aims at achieving greatest good for greatest numbers of people.

Significance of Utilitarianism

1. Helps in making informed choices -> civil servants can know that a decision is right is it affects majority of people positively. 2. This theory can be easily implemented -> policy formulation becomes easy when this principle is kept in mind. 3. Centered on humanity -> this doctrine aims to increase well-being of humanity. 4. Provides universal solution -> This theory in a way provides solution to the problem by keeping majority happiness in mind. 5. Morality is not subjective and can be projected from this theory as it shows which moral belief is true & which is false.

Limitations

1. Neglect minority -> while keeping in mind benefit of majority, benefit of minority and vulnerable are disregarded. 2. Primacy to outcomes and not to the means can promote unethical practices. Eg:- Slavery is justified in utilitarian principle as it benefits majority of agrarian economy, but it is morally wrong as it does not respect human dignity. 3. Utilitarianism promotes selfishness -> Strict adherence to these philosophy can make people selfish as people will work to promote self good in the attempt to justify his good as good of majority. 4. Consequences of an action are not immediate -> therefore it is not possible to gauge on the right or wrong of an action until true result comes out. 5. Utilitarianism only promotes black & white construct of morality -> There can be a gray area too as when removing encroachments from roadside prior warning can help roadside vendors to protect their property rather than demolishing the shope right away.