Moonlighting refers to doing a second job, typically at night and secretly, in addition to one's regular employment. With work from home becoming a new feature of many jobs, it has become easy for many people to moonlight. Arvind is a software engineer in Comsoft, an MNC, and he works from home for his firm. Arvind has received only meagre salary hikes in the last two years as the business of Comsoft has suffered due to the pandemic. However, his expenditure has increased substantially as he got married and had a child in these two years. Arvind was finding it difficult to make his ends meet and decided to take up another job, apart from his regular job in Comsoft. He got his second gig at Mocsoft, who happened to be a competitor of Comsoft, and thus, started moonlighting. This side gig was very helpful for Arvind and his financial condition started improving. Arvind found that in Mocsoft, his role and responsibilities were quite similar to that in his regular employment at Comsoft. This meant that he could easily manoeuvre between two jobs without compromising the quality of work in either company. Shift timing of both the jobs were also different. To keep the two jobs separate, he used his official computer to work for Comsoft and his personal computer for Mocsoft. Two jobs gave Arvind financial space to save for buying a house, something the couple had always dreamt of. However, all his plans shattered and his world came crashing down when Arvind received an official mail from Comsoft informing him of his termination with immediate effect citing his second job as the reason for termination. Arvind was clueless as to what to do now and how to tell his wife about his termination. Similar is the story of hundreds of Arvind, who were terminated for moonlighting. a) Analyze the various ethical issues involved in the case of moonlighting. b) Do you think Comsoft's decision to terminate the employment of Arvind is justified? Why or why not? c) Identify various qualities which could help Arvind handle this situation.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
The case of job termination was faced by many like Arvind. Moonlighting has thus got many ethical issues involved.
a) Ethical issues in moonlighting 1. Conflict of interest when both the companies are competitors (eg. in Arvind's case) 2. Loyalty to a company v/s added financial burden. 3. Personal integrity v/s realities of time 4. Being steadfast v/s Being practical
Therefore Moonlighting has emerged as a practical option for many like Arvind due to the changing dynamics and realities of time.
b) Was Comsoft's decision to terminate Arvind justified? Comsoft's decision to terminate Arvind's employment can be justified on the grounds that: - Arvind worked for a competitor company and thus was disloyal to Comsoft. - Arvind took no prior permission. - If Comsoft's employment policy stated clearly that an employee can't avail any other job, then the decision of firing Arvind was valid. - Threat of secrets of the company getting revealed before a competitor.
However, Comsoft could have first informed Arvind that an enquiry would be initiated rather than directly firing him.
c) Qualities to help Arvind handle the situation The situation that Arvind had already brought himself into gives him two choices:
Choice 1: Convince Comsoft of his situation and his loyalty towards work and the experience he has gained in it. If they allow him to keep his job then he can. If they allow him only after resignation from the other job, he should make a cost benefit analysis.
However if they refuse at all cost, then comes choice 2.
Choice 2: Arvind can continue working for Mocsoft to at least keep one source of income steady. Then he can go through the employee rules of Mocsoft and learn if he can avail some other job or not, and then act accordingly.
If they allow, he can find another job. If they don't, he should then think of an alternate source of income.
Qualities like persuasion, dedication, positive attitude, hardwork and responsibility will help him continue.