Topper Copies

Anand Singh is a government bus conductor working with the Nav Pradesh Transport Corporation. Anand has completed 35 years of service and is due for retirement next year. Anand is happy because he is hopeful of getting his daughter, Madhvi, married from the money he will receive as his retirement benefits. However, Anand's wife pesters him to earn more money in one way or the other. Anand likes his job, and all the passengers in his route vouch for his good nature and helpful behaviour. One day, Suresh, Anand's boss, called Anand in his cabin. He told Anand that a complaint has been filed against him by a person for illegally taking the ticket money from him without issuing the receipt for the ticket. Suresh explained to Anand that this act amounted to misappropriation of government money. Suresh always saw Anand as a decent individual and he asked him as to why he indulged in such an act? Anand, visibly disturbed, told Suresh that as the conductor of a government bus he receives a meagre salary, grossly insufficient to meet the needs of his family. He told him that his younger daughter, Sarita, suffers from chronic kidney ailment, and requires dialysis twice a week. A huge chunk of his paltry salary goes towards the cost of Sarita's treatment. Moreover, as a single bread-winner of the family, he has to cater to the needs of his elderly parents. Anand further tells Suresh that since last one year a substantial portion of his income goes towards repaying the loan that he took for his elder daughter's college education. Anand laments that even after working for 35 long years, he is unable to provide for his family beyond the bare basic necessities. He tells Suresh that he is aware of many incidents of large-scale corruption in the road transport department that go virtually unnoticed. Further, Anand justifies his act of taking money by highlighting that almost every colleague of his indulges in such practices, and in comparison to them, what he took, just fifty rupees, is ignorable and paltry. Further, he brought to light the fact that at times they, the conductors, were expected to give their immediate superiors a bribe in the name of convenience fees for various official tasks. While listening to Anand, Suresh feels compassion for him. He decides to verify the veracity of Anand's claim with regard to the dire straits of his financial conditions. On enquiry, all the workers in the office attested to the fact that Anand is going through a very bad phase and that he frequently resorts to short term loans in order to meet his financial requirements. Moreover, the office employees requested Suresh to take a lenient view of Anand's case. They were of the view that if a strong action is taken over such a trivial incident, then it would be highly unjust and unfair towards Anand. On reaching his home, Suresh shared the whole occurrence and Anand's story with his wife. To his surprise, his wife too agreed with the employees of the office. She told him that such small incidents are a routine matter. Also, with rising inflation and increasing obligations, this is the only way for people like Anand to make their ends meet. She asks Suresh to not waste his time and energy over such a small matter. Suresh knows Anand as a hard-working individual who has many mouths to feed at home. Suresh shares genuine sympathy with him, however, he also understands that embezzlement of government money, irrespective of amount and circumstances, is wrong. Now he is in a state of dilemma over his course of action. a) Why are the incidents of petty corruption trivialized? According to you, is it justifiable to ignore small incidents of corruption? b) What are various ethical dilemmas in the above case study? c) Discuss the merits and demerits of various options available to Suresh. Also, what, according to you, will be the ideal course of action and why?

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

In the above case, Suresh faces a real dilemma over the issue of taking action against Anand and this should take a decision as per conscience.

a) Why petty corruption is trivialized Incidents of petty corruption are widely seen being done and ignored across organizations - govt and private. They are trivialized because: 1. Work culture has become like this. 2. Opaqueness in the functioning of institutions 3. Fear of missing out culture 4. People fear reporting and indulging in low cases thus the doers of corruption are encouraged. 5. Mere greed

It should be an unjustifiable issue to ignore such corruption cases. Corruption breeds more corruption and therefore should be condemned in any manner, irrespective of the amount.

However, in the eye of public services, society is complex. The action and the strict implementation of punishment should not follow a water tight compartment approach and should vary from case to case basis.

b) Ethical dilemmas in the above case study - Rule of organization v/s Dire situation of Anand. - Strict penalty v/s His family and problems. - Utmost righteousness v/s Empathy - Integrity v/s Compassion.

c) Options available to Suresh Option 1 - Forego Anand's corruption calling it a petty incident. By this he will help Anand but Anand might be susceptible to do further and bigger such incidents. Further it impacts integrity of Suresh.

Option 2 - Get Anand fired. This would make Suresh hold his upright values and take action against Anand. However, it will make Anand miserable and will badly hit a six member family.

Option 3 - Suresh can give strict warning to Anand and make him believe that future action will be taken against him if found. This will make him do his duty. Foregoing his act this time will make him manage his finances and keep his job.

Thus option 3 will be an ideal course of action because society can't progress without emotional intelligence and compassion of a human towards other. This situation was an exception to the steadfast corruption violation situation and decision should therefore be dependent on case to case basis.