Topper Copies

"Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." In the context of this statement, bring out the ethical issues involved with creating a surveillance state for the sake of national security.

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

It is said that when police states are created, it is created in the name of national security and interest of people, convincing people of their best yet to come, gradually taking away all the human rights and freedoms.

Therefore, surveillance and dictatorship today can't bring democracy and freedom tommorow. Freedom and essential liberty are components of human life that shouldn't be foregone at any cost.

For instance, Adolf Hitler promised to bring development and to make Germany great. He demanded a surveillance authoritarian state for a while. People deliberately ignored atrocities on the jews and the warmongering attitude of Hitler for national security. They gave up essential liberty for temporary safety from jews who were blamed to take over businesses of the country.

The result is history as the people of Germany were the ultimate loosers for years to come even after the war ended.

Therefore, more than the state itself, it is the responsibility of the people to not forego their essential liberty for temporary short term benefit, for such people are taken for granted by the state.

Ethical issues involved: 1. National Security r/s Freedom 2. Police state v/s Human Rights 3. Authoritarianism v/s Democracy. 4. Temporary safety v/s Forever liberty.