Topper Copies

"Legalizing the Minimum Support Price (MSP) would create more challenges than it resolves." Comment.

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

MSP refers to minimum price guarantee provided on 23 crops by govt to support farmers and prevent price crash.

MSP regime - Covers 23 crops -> cereals -> wheat, rice; Pulses -> moong, tur; cash crop -> copra, cotton - Decided by CACP on the basis of A2+FL - Final announcement by CCEA - Revised before every cropping season & procured through APMC networks

Why demand for legalisation 1. Farm bill controversy -> farmers felt govt is dismantling MSP 2. Rising uncertainities in farming sector -> climate shocks, extreme weather events etc 3. Reducing crop productivity -> need of govt. assurance (eg) Heatwaves reducing wheat production 4. Dependency Syndrome -> MSP has made farmers continuously dependent 5. Market shocks :- MSP gives cushion 6. Punjab & Haryana -> major benefactor -> main demand of these farmers

Challenges 1. Perpetuates dependency on MSP and subsidies -> (eg) 2% of GDP on subsidy 2. Skewed distribution -> 80% procurement from punjab & haryana 3. Lack of capacity of storage with APMC -> legalisation will lead to wastage 4. Market distortion -> demand & supply logic will fail 5. Monoculture of wheat-rice -> affect crop diversification efforts of govt 6. Substantial burden on exchequer -> 72000 cr on just few crop procurement 7. Environmental challenges -> soil fertility, water mngmt. 8. WTO challenge -> Red box as subsidy as challenged for the 9. Export distortion as prices are high compared to international prices 10. FCI buffer stock excessive storage leads to food wastage :- 92000 cr (NITI)

Way ahead - PM AASHA -> PSS, PDPS, MIS - Ashok Dalwai -> MSP must be expanded - Swaminathan -> C2+50% - Ashok Gulati :- Income policy