The principle of impartiality may conflict with the need for compassion towards marginalized communities. Discuss in the context of civil services in India.
Apurva Verma, AIR 42, 2025
Impartiality is the first virtue in any civil service. It refers to treating everyone alike without any discrimination. However, even our constitution encompasses positive discrimination.
Impartiality in context of civil services in India
Fig: Impartiality and its impacts
1. India has a large population under poverty. Impartiality may not be completely useful in ensuring socio-economic development. - Eg: Starvation deaths in Jharkhand due to strict adherence to rules. 2. Affirmative justice is compromised: - Article-14: Equals should be treated alike. However, for affirmative policies, positive discrimination has to be done. 3. Impartiality may not suffice in case of marginalised sections unaware of their rights. 4. Impartiality gives importance to institutions over population for whom they have been created.
Impartiality is essential but it is not mandatory when it comes to ensuring socio-economic justice.