ONE MAY SNATCH A NAP AMIDST RAGING FIRE BUT CANNOT SLEEP A WINK IN POVERTY DIRE
Rupal Jaiswal, AIR 43, 2025
In a thatched hut, Vimla screeched in pain. She was quick with child but no midwife let alone a doctor by her side.
Her husband and father in law sat outside the hut, mulling over how will they feed a child, if ever it was born alive. Ultimately, Vimla dies in labour.
Munshi Premchand in aforesaid novella "Kafan" then describes how the two men adopt illegal means to buy a "Kafan" (or shroud) for dead woman. The two, sitting by her pyre, spend another sleepless night on hungry, growling bellies.
Munshi Premchand, quite vividly presents how even a wink of sleep evades the poor.
In this essay, we shall explore the luxury of nap, and who really gets to sleep peacefully in this unequal world. Thereafter, we shall discuss how even the most affluent can lose sleep. Finally, we shall explore ways and means to correct the sleeplessness.
Luxury of a nap amidst raging fire
When there is fire all around, sleeping can prove fatal. Here, fire can broadly be understood as either a crisis, disaster or any other adversity.
However, some people are privileged enough to afford a short nap in this hour of urgency.
When Bengal saw a famine in 1872 and then again in 1943, the "annadata" were scrambling for food, while the Governor General of Bengal slept peacefully in his luxurious fort.
Similarly, when today the fire of climate change is raging all across the world; Pacific Small Island States cannot catch a wink while overseas territories of French like Reunion are able to get a nap. This is despite the fact that Reunion itself faces threat of submergence.
Why do they have this luxury of nap? Because they have a fall back mechanism. Reunion residents have France to go to while the then Governor General's food was responsibility of the British Crown.
Thus, while fires rage all around, the privileged and the powerful still have luxury of a nap. However, while the first world sleeps, the third world weeps.
Sleepless nights for the poor
"Sleeplessness" can arise from the pangs of hunger. However, on a broad view, sleeplessness is also a result of economic troubles, familial issues, the agony of social isolation or even environmental injustice.
In recognition of the utter marginalization that an economically poor person faces, Swami Vivekananda once said "It is a sin to teach religion or talk politics to a hungry man!"
As Vimala in "Kafan" saw the worst night due to lack of "institutional delivery", several women today are mired in poverty. "Time poverty" is one aspect of this which forces women to spend many a sleepless nights.
On the same lines, several Denotified Tribes (who were once declared "criminal by birth" by the British) spend their lives in shadows of their past. They are condemned to "employment/occupational poverty" - taking up manual scavenging, and other menial works in distress.
Other cases of sleeplessness are even more dire - children trafficked and sexually exploited; specially abled persons seen as "object of charity"; pavement dwellers in fear of being run over.
All these cases share one commonality - dignity evades them during the day while sleep evades them at night. The sole reason for the restless nights being the monstrous poverty - of one form or the other.
Despite this strong correlation between poverty and inability to sleep, it would be wrong to conclude that it is only the poor who cannot catch a wink of sleep.
Affluence can also cause sleeplessness
Samuel Coleridge in his poem "Rime of the Ancient Mariner" wittingly writes:
"Water water everywhere Not a single drop to drink"
Here, he has highlighted how abundance of something does not mean peaceful contentment.
Such abundance which is acquired by unethical or illegal means pricks one's conscience. It causes a cognitive dissonance and a battle of man against himself.
In case of fugitive offenders like Nirav Modi and Vijay Mallya, inability of catching a wink of sleep is because of "Sophocles' dagger" dangling above them (ie. legal consequences await them).
Further, having high aspirations in life can also lead to the dreamer losing sleep. Pradeep Kumar Jena (IAS) worked tirelessly during Odisha's cyclone relief camps with his team.
The noble dedication to service caused several "COVID warrior" doctors and nurses to altruistically give up the luxury of nap that they could have enjoyed. After all like John Stuart Mill once said "it is better to be a Socrates dissatisfied, than a fool satisfied." Thus, while catching a nap may be the best thing to do during fires all around, it is the cause of humanity that keeps several good samaritans awake.
A magnanimous nap for all
Aristotle, in all his wisdom, once said "Hope is a waking dream". If we can believe in a just world which ensures that none goes to bed hungry, then we shall be truly awaken our spirits to work towards this goal.
Before delving into the means of ensuring a good night's sleep for the poor, we must understand the work that needs to be done during the day.
Firstly, a social order that does not discriminate is mandatory; to eliminate poverty caused by marginalization. Smash the prejudices by unveiling John Rawls' "Veil of Ignorance" and thereby create a fair society.
Secondly, putting a living wage in the economically distressed people's hands should be targetted. Only then Gandhiji's Talisman of "Antyodaya se Sarvodaya" can be achieved.
Thirdly, to counter the "poverty of a dignified existence" like those that vulnerable children, LGBTQs etc. are experiencing, government policies infused with care ethics and discourse ethics must be framed.
Lastly, avoiding an unethical nap while the world around is in flames can go a long way in ensuring no one falls through the cracks of a good night.
To conclude, a nap though comes easily to some privileged people, it can never ensure a refreshment unless all those who are deprived of it are brought on an equal pedestal. The pangs of unavailable accessibility of food, water, housing must be eradicated. A Sanskrit "sukti" goes thus:
"Prithivyam Trini Ratnani, Jalam, Annam, Subhashitam Mudhe pashan khandeshu Ratnasangya vidhiyate"
[The earth has only three precious things - food, water and good/kind speech. Stupid are those who grant title of treasure to stones.]
Thus, our collective conscience and actions must be directed towards service of "daridra narayan" so that they can peacefully avail the essence of a nap.