IF LIBERTY MEANS ANYTHING AT ALL, IT MEANS THE RIGHT TO TELL PEOPLE WHAT THEY DO NOT WANT TO HEAR.
Rupal Jaiswal, AIR 43, 2025
It was a bright sunny day. Several citizens of the Greek city state had gathered in townhall. They were about to witness a voice of dissent being silenced forever.
A pot of Hemlock was brought to the man who had allegedly corrupted the youth of Athens through his speeches - his dialectical method of learning which raised questions that the Athenian rulers did not want to hear.
This man was Socrates and as he drank the poison, liberty was killed along with him.
Thus, George Orwell rightly remarked "If liberty means anything at all, it means the power to tell others what they don't want to hear".
In this essay, we shall delve into the right to free speech as the essence of liberty and why others do not want to hear this voice of liberty. We shall also discuss other aspects of liberty and its interaction with restraint.
Right to tell: the essence of liberty
Liberty means freedom - the freedom to question, the freedom to dissent and the freedom to express oneself. This was the freedom the French were asking for as they stormed the Bastille. The clarion call of ensuing French Revolution was "Viva la Liberte" - long live liberty.
This call echoes in the pages of history - Galileo and Copernicus sought to tell scientific truths that the Church did not want to hear.
Similarly, Indian press through Samvad Kaumudi, Mirat-ul-Akbar, Kesari were trying to exercise their freedom to tell the British colonialists what they did not want to hear.
Liberty, thus, means the freedom of speech and expression of contrary ideas, howsoever distasteful to the audience.
One pertinent question arises here - why do people not want to hear?
Men fear truth
The most dreaded right in this world today is the right to speak truth. Truth has the power to bring revolution; it can bring light where darkness prevails. But the greatest tragedy of mankind is "men are afraid of the light". And therefore, they do not want to hear what others say.
When Narendra Dabholkar and Gauri Lankesh, two prominent rationalists, who sought to dispel superstitions, exercised their right to tell the society that their dogmas are mere rubbish, they were murdered.
Similarly, when women wrestlers like Vinesh Phogat levelled sexual harassment allegations against a powerful politician and WFI chief, it was not well received.
The fear of truth has led even democracies to use spyware (like Pegasus). Michael Foucault has expressed concern over the so-called "surveillance by libertarian states" as the biggest threat to right to speech.
However, fear of truth is not the only reason why others do not want to hear opinions. The "so-called" need to maintain status quoism is another reason why free speech is restricted.
In this scenario, "1984" novel of George Orwell comes to mind. The authoritarian "Big Brother" had ironically installed "The Ministry of Truth" to maintain his own power over what citizens speak.
Such totalitarian regimes are guided by self-interest - and in such states, the right to tell truly is a charade. But like Aristotle said "One must speak truth to power". What then are the consequences of a liberal society where right to speak is cherished?
Where there is say, there is a way
When citizens in a democracy are allowed to voice their opinions, it ensures resilience. Take the example of India - when most of India's neighbours have collapsed in the face of authoritarian regimes, India remains a stellar democracy.
When Balasore train tragedy took several passengers' lives, or when the Kolkata resident doctor's murder case came to light, it was collective freedom to speak that has set the government's wheels into motion.
In the economic sphere, several economists disagree with RBI's Monetary Policy and are free to pen articles on the same. Raghuram Rajan, for example, has even attacked RBI over its failure to keep inflation under check.
Similarly, social media has enabled "wisdom being radiated" from all sides. #MeToo movement and #ReclaimTheNight movements are all examples of Indian women speaking truth to power.
Continuing the tradition of rightful exercise of speech, artists like MF Hussain depicted the perceived taboo ie. the anatomy of female body - in full glory, naked. The society may have shunned him for it, but liberty stood up for him.
The aforesaid illustrations reflect the power of freedom of speech. From ensuring accountability to ventilation of grievances by vulnerable sections, freedom to tell is a precious gem. It must not be lost.
But liberty is more than just freedom of speech
Freedom of speech may be an important part of liberty but is mere speech enough? The historically marginalized LGBTQ community will definitely say NO! They reclaimed their right to sexual orientation (ie. right to express) but the Supreme Court in Supriyo Chakraborty v/s Union of India shattered their dream of a legally recognized same-sex marriage.
Clearly, liberty means a life of dignity. When Nobel Laureate Kailash Satyarthi started "Narmada Bachpan Bachao Andolan", he was not aiming for freedom to tell - instead he wanted "freedom to enjoy childhood" for the child labourers.
In a similar vein, the youth of Bangladesh forced the former PM to step down - not because they were solely looking for freedom of speech but because they wanted liberty to be represented by a government which upholds probity.
Thus, liberty is a rainbow - it creates an aesthetic society and a beautiful nation.
But with great power/rights come great responsibility. Thus liberty then must be exercised in a way that it does not harm others.
Restrained liberty is true liberty
When Voltaire said "I may not agree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it", he was emphasizing how liberty of speech should be coupled with respect for others' liberty.
This is where the importance of restraint must be witnessed. The trend of cancel culture on social media which creates echo chambers highlights misuse of liberty.
Similarly, an industrialist who claims liberty of markets often snatches liberty of own labourers to a "living wage".
These instances highlight how liberty of one may lead to chains for another. To counter this, our Constitution also provides "reasonable restrictions" on "freedom of speech" (Art 19).
Additionally, Buddha's noble way of "Right speech, Right Belief, Right conduct" exhorts one to exercise restraint while exercising liberty. An ancient sanskrit shloka goes "Ais Vaani Boliye, mann ka Aapa Khoye; Auro ko sheetal kare, ap bhi sheetal hoye" (When speaking, speak with due regard for others - so that they are calmed by your words - that is true liberty").