Topper Copies

How is Rostow's stages of growth different from Marxian stages of growth?

Nesrin P Fasim, AIR 703, 2024

Stages of growth were explained by both Marx and Rostow that provides description of how an economic system progresses in its growth path.

Brief model of Marx & Rostow

Marx's stages of growth

→ Based on dialectic materialism

Stages: 1. Primitive communal stage → where tribal society and clans lived using menial jobs and had only production for their needs. 2. Slavery - where people exploited people 3. Feudalism - where large land owners extracted surplus from the land and the serfs were exploited from surplus. 4. Capitalism - gradual shift to capital based manufacturing sectors and creation of industrial reserve army → where the capital controlled labour → later reduction in profits of capitalists due to complete displacement of labour. 5. Socialism - withering away of state and proletariat over capitalists

Rostow's stages of growth

1. Primitive society who lives on Pre-Newtonian science & technology. 2. Pre-conditions of take off → start of conditions for higher sustained growth like shifting to higher social overhead capital & making ideal conditions for take off. 3. Take off - sustained growth of economy with increase in investment being around 5%-10% of the total GNP and sectoral growth also increasing. 4. Drive to maturity - the society & economy reaping benefits of take off stage such that all the sectors are having an ideal growth. 5. Age of high mass consumption - where the economy changes from a production oriented to a consumption oriented society with huge consumer base for produced goods.

Differences

| Marx | Rostow | |---|---| | Explained the theory on the basis of historical timeline. | Never had a historical perspective, rather explained just how different stages look like. | | Considered both economic & non-economic factors | Relied purely on economic factors. | | Considered labour and capital relations to explain things | Didn't consider more on labour-capital relations. | | Mostly based on societal evolution in different societies | Did not consider real life of all societies. It mainly focused on America's economy's growth. | | Assumed that a stateless society possible | No such assumption, only works with state. | | Didn't focus on growth rates & investment | Focused on growth rates & investment. |

However both theories were similar in certain aspects: → tried to study evolution of an economy. → connected to how social relations feed economic relations. → showed the zenith of growth phases.

Both the theories hold prominence in the present context owing to different geo-political situations in explaining different countries' growth path.