Topper Copies

Explain the points of agreement and difference between Friedman's monetarist restatement of the quantity theory and the Keynesian theory of money demand.

Mohd Ashfaq, AIR 770, 2023

Friedman reinterpreted the Quantity theory of Money propounded by classicals. Monetarists under Friedman agreed with the Keynesian theory of money demand on many grounds. They agreed that Money demand depends on nominal Income. But, Monetarists and Keynesians differed from each other on many grounds.

Difference (1) M => Money demand is stable K => Money demand is unstable. It changes with the public confidence in economy.

(2) M => recognizes different aspects of money demand but doesn't find it helpful to separate them based on use of money. K => Identifies three different kinds of use for which money is demanded. (a) Transaction demand (b) Speculative demand (c) Possessive demand.

(3) M => Broad choice available to people as alternative to money: Bonds and durable goods. K => Considers a narrow choice of alternatives to holding money: Only Money or Bonds.

(4) M => Velocity of money is not constant. It depends on the rate of return on assets alternative to money. K => Considered velocity of money as constant.

(5) M => Interest elasticity of money demand is very low. K => Interest elasticity of Money demand is high.

(6) M => Md = K(r,B,D,rF)PY K => Md = KPY.