Critically examine H-O model.
Nesrin P Fasim, AIR 703, 2024
The Heckscher-Ohlin model is an old trade theory which states that there will be trade by when a country specialises and exports those commodities in which it has abundant higher factor intensity & imports those commodities that it has less factor intensity
eg:- Labour intensive commodities will be produced and exported by a labour abundant country.
Assumptions: - 2 country x 2 commodities x 2 factor model - zero transportation cost - full employment. - perfect factor mobility within country & imperfect factor mobility within countries.
Consider country 1 - labour intensive (commodity X) country 2 - commodity Y - capital intensive
[production-possibility diagram: commodity Y on the vertical axis, commodity X on the horizontal; country 1's offer curve reaches equilibrium E on price line Px/Py=1 and the highest attainable indifference curve IC; exports of Y and imports of X by country 2, exports of X and imports of Y by country 1 marked]
The Heckscher-Ohlin equilibrium takes place at E where the price line and the highest most indifference curve intersects such that country 1 that specialises in X exports X and country 2 that specialises in Y exports Y. They import the other commodity in which they have no factor abundance from the other country.
However the H-O theory was tested and had different conclusions:
Leontief Paradox
An American economist Leontief took data from 1947-1953 based on input-output table and found contradictory results. America being a capital abundant country should have exported capital-intensive commodities and import labour-abundant commodities. From his data, it turned out that the US imports were 30% less labour intensive.
In 1956 again checked and found 6% less labour intensive imports.
This anomaly was explained as: - Roden → Leontief didn't count the natural resources. - Due to high tariff policies of US on labour-intensive imports. - Kravis gave a valid explanation that this is because the US labour was more skilled such that human capital should be counted as capital, hence the exports are capital-intensive. - Leontief himself gave explanation that this was due to high efficiency of US labour - 3 times more efficient.
However, later several empirical studies took place. Readen → conducted a study across 12 factors & 26 countries and found that the H-O theory holds true in all the cases.
Broader conclusions on several studies showed that H-O theory is valid in case of bilateral trade when the economies are at close distance and their trade is based on factor-abundance.
H-O theory hence holds a special place due to its explanation of inter-industry trade and factor abundance as a factor affecting trade.