What happens if LM is vertical in case of fiscal and monetary expansion. How will your answer change if LM is standard but IS is vertical.
R Sri Rusat, AIR 52, 2024
LM curve shows the combination of points where asset and money market are in equilibrium for given interest rate and output.
When LM is vertical (A) Fiscal Expansion [an IS-LM graph with a vertical LM curve and IS shifting right to IS', interest rate rising from r0 to r1 at fixed output YN]
In (A), The IS curve shifts to the right, in this case, the output is fixed same. Only the interest rate rises from r0 to r1 due to higher income chasing the constant supply of goods.
(B) Monetary Expansion [an IS-LM graph with LM shifting right to LM', interest rate falling from r to r', output rising from Y to Y']
The output increases from Y to Y' and r reduces to r'. Therefore, monetary policy is effective.
When IS is vertical (A) Fiscal expansion [an IS-LM graph with a vertical IS curve shifting right to IS', LM curve, interest rate rising from r to r', output rising from Y to Y']
When IS curve is vertical, then fiscal expansion increases the IS to right to IS' increasing output from Y to Y' and interest rate from r to r'. Hence, Fiscal policy is effective.
(B) Monetary Expansion [an IS-LM graph with a vertical IS curve, LM shifting right to LM', output remaining constant at Y]
Here, r increases to r' with Y remaining constant. Hence, monetary policy is ineffective.
Therefore, when IS is vertical then the monetary policy is effective but when LM is vertical fiscal policy is effective.