Topper Copies

Is it always true that direct subsidy makes an individual better off than indirect subsidy of the same amount?

Mohd Ashfaq, AIR 770, 2023

Direct subsidy involves actual payments in "cash or kind" to the individuals. Eg: direct benefit transfer of "LPG" subsidy.

Δ Whereas, indirect subsidies do not involve actual payments. They are directed to benefit the individuals in form of less prices, cut in taxes, subsidized loans, etc. Δ Indirect subsidies cause distortions in production or consumption in the market. They create inefficiency and result in deadweight loss.

[graph: P on Y axis, Q on X axis; S and D curves crossing, and a supply-with-subsidy curve shifted right; P, P*, Ps marked on the price axis, Q and Q* marked on the quantity axis; two triangles, a and b, shaded as the deadweight loss]

An indirect subsidy given to producers, such as input subsidy on fertilizers, to reduce their prices for the benefit of individuals, creates deadweight loss (DWL). Δ The producers receive a higher price 'P', and the consumers can purchase products at the subsidized price.

Δ Triangle 'a' in the diagram represents welfare cost due to distortion in production (excess production). Δ Triangle 'b' represents cost in welfare due to distortion in consumption (excess consumption).

Δ A direct subsidy such as cash payments, can also provide the same benefit to the individuals, but without creating welfare loss. Δ Hence Individuals are always better off with direct subsidy.