Topper Copies

Critically examine how Keynesian speculative demand for money is different from Cambridge incorporation of K?

Rahul Hijam, AIR 740, 2023

Keynesian Speculative demand

Keynesian money demand is given by Md = Ky - hi

It is determined by: a) Transaction demand for money where higher income will mean higher increase in transaction demand of money b) Precautionary demand for money which is directly related to income c) Speculative demand for money which is affected by interest rate.

According to Keynes, interest rate and bond price are inversely related. A high bond price will imply a relatively lesser interest rate but when bond price is high, the market speculates that it will fall in future and people hold currency waiting for bond price to fall. This is Keynesian speculative demand for money.

The Cambridge Cash Balance Theory is based on transaction demand for money. The theory is represented by Md = K.P.Y where K is a constant fraction of nominal GDP that people will use for transaction.

Here K is not defined rigorously i.e. factors affecting K were not mentioned. Cambridge's K was volatile i.e. it fluctuated over time period because it was affected by animal spirits, as suggested by Pigou.

Therefore, 1. While Keynes's theory talks about speculative demand, Cambridge 'K' lacks it. 2. There is proper definition of speculative demand given by Keynes while Cambridge 'K' lacks proper definition. 3. Also unlike Keynes's speculative demand for money, Cambridge K did not recognise that real balances are linearly related in terms of market to financial assets.