Topper Copies

Examine the validity of Arrow's Impossibility Theorem in the light of its criticisms.

Mohd Ashfaq, AIR 770, 2023

Arrow's Impossibility theorem states that it is certainly impossible to make social choice entirely based on individual choice. Any social welfare decision that depends on individual decisions violates atleast one of the following principles. (i) Transitivity of preferences (ii) Social choice must be responsive to individual preferences (iii) Condition of non-imposition (iv) Condition of non-dictatorship (v) Independence of irrelevant alternatives.

Arrow states that what majority of the people want in a society may not result in maximum welfare. He states that social choice cannot be based on individuals because individuals may be consistent, but the resulting social decision may be contradictory. Eg: Condorcet Paradox of democracy.

Criticisms and Implications Δ Impossibility arises not due to dependency of social decisions on individual preferences, but because of choices being made based on a limited set of information. Δ Availability of perfect and free information is not possible in the real world. As long as information is incomplete, Arrow's theory is valid. Δ Using "interpersonal comparisons", to tackle the impossibility. But it is not often possible to accurately devise parameters for such comparisons. As long as interpersonal comparisons are not possible, Arrow's Impossibility is valid. Δ Those decisions that relate to just a "community" of an individual are not a matter of social choice. But Tony Mills, stresses on minority rights to ensure moral social decisions, invalidates this criticism.