Topper Copies

Explain the different concepts of excess capacity, highlighting differences between Chamberlin and Robinson.

R Sri Rusat, AIR 52, 2024

Excess capacity in a monopoly condition refers the production of individual firm's output below the social optimum level of output.

Normal Excess capacity [a cost-curve graph with MC, LAC, AC curves; point E where MC=MR and point A at the minimum of LAC, with the gap between quantities y1 and y2 marked as excess capacity]

In the above fig 1, the Excess capacity is the difference between the point E, where MC=MR and point A minimum of LAC.

Chamberlin's Excess Capacity Chamberlin assumes that the excess capacity is due to the difference between output produced because of perceived demand curve and the minimum of LAC.

1. Perceived demand curve -> when individual firm takes the decision different from the group of firm's decision 2. Proportional demand curve -> when group of firm together takes the pricing decision

[a similar cost-curve graph with dd, dd', SAC, SMC, AR, MR curves and excess capacity marked between y1 and y2]

From the above diagram we get the following: 1. When individual firm reduces the output to increase its price then dd shifts towards left to dd' 2. At the point A, the output is produced at y1 3. But the socially optimum level of output is produced at y2 (i.e) minimum of LAC 4. Therefore, the Excess capacity here arises because of difference between y1 and y2 5. Chamberlin often attributes the cost of excess capacity to the differentiation cost of the firm

Joan Robinson's Excess capacity [a cost-curve graph with SMC, SAC, LAC, AR, MR curves, points A, B, E, and quantities y1, y2, y3 marking the long run excess capacity]

In the above figure 3, Joan Robinson contends the following: 1. Excess capacity is a phenomenon of long run when the monopoly produces the output at y1, less than socially optimum output at y3

However, later economists pointed out that if Monopolists were to keep their price so high, then it will lead to entry of more firms thereby reducing the price of the products. Hence, they classified Joan Robinson's excess capacity into short run excess capacity and long run excess capacity.

Chamberlin versus Joan Robinson's Excess capacity

| Chamberlin | Joan Robinson | |---|---| | There is no such classification of short run and long run excess capacity | There is only long run excess capacity possibility | | The monopoly firms sell homogeneous products | The monopoly firms sell substitute product | | The concept of "perceived" and "proportional" demand curve is introduced | No such concept of perceived and proportional demand curve introduced |

Nevertheless, Excess capacity is generally considered as a loss in the output for market as otherwise would be achieved using the perfect competition.