Topper Copies

How is Cambridge theory different from Fisher?

Rahul Hijam, AIR 740, 2023

Cambridge Cash Balance Theory was brought by Marshall & Pigou. It is given by the equation: Md = K.P.Y where Md = Transaction demand of money K = fraction of nominal GDP held in terms of money. P = Price Y = Income

The theory is based on transaction demand for money i.e. money will be demanded in fixed proportion to change in nominal GDP. According to the theory there is linear relation between nominal GDP and money demand.

However 'K' was not defined rigorously i.e. factors affecting K was not mentioned. It was assumed that policy makers will have all information about relation between money demand and demand for other assets.

Also Cambridge's K was not volatile because of animal spirits. Monetary Policy did not have any effect (real) as change in money supply will not change K.

However, Fisher's theory is given by equation M.V = P.Y It can be rewritten as: M = (1/V) P.Y (where 1/V can be 'K'.)

The difference from Cambridge theory is that Fisher assumed V to be constant which is constant velocity of money circulation because of 1. Institutional factors like existence of banks 2. Behavioural factors like usage of near money 3. Technological substitutes.

And all these factors don't change immediately.

Thus Cambridge theory was more volatile and dependent on animal spirits while Fisher's theory was more stable and took into account behavioural and institutional factors.