"Marshallian stability ensures Walrasian stability." Do you agree?
Mohd Ashfaq, AIR 770, 2023
Marshallian and Walrasian approaches of Price determination are interdependent.
Marshall considers that quantity demanded and quantity supplied together decide the price. Equilibrium price is achieved when Qd = Qs.
Whereas, Walras considers that adjustments in price determine the equilibrium levels of Qd & Qs.
But, stability in Marshallian equilibrium doesn't always ensure Walrasian stability.
Case I: Marshallian stability ensures Walrasian stability [graph: price-quantity diagram (m) with S and D curves converging to Q*, and a paired diagram (w) with S and D curves converging to P*, showing P1, P2 either side of P*]
Case II: Marshallian stability doesn't ensure Walrasian stability [graph: price-quantity diagram (m), stable, S and D lines with Q' and Q* marked; paired diagram (w), unstable, S and D lines with P* and P1 marked, arrows diverging] stable => unstable Q.