Substitution effect is the deciding factor about the nature of goods. Comment.
Mohd Ashfaq, AIR 770, 2023
Substitution effect refers to the change in demand of a product as a result of change in its price or the price of a closely related product.
Substitution effect (SE) along with Income effect (IE) is responsible for deciding the nature of goods.
Normal Goods [graph: indifference curves with a budget line shifting outward on Y-X axes, SE from point a to b and IE from b to c]
For normal goods the income effect is always positive and substitution effect is always negative. dx/dp < 0 & dx/dm > 0
Inferior Goods [graph: indifference curves with a budget line shifting on Y-X axes, points a, b, c] SE > IE
For inferior goods IE is negative (dx/dm < 0) and SE is also negative (dx/dp < 0). ∴ The overall effect depends on the strength of both SE & IE. When substitution effect is greater than Income effect, it is an Inferior good.
Giffen Goods IE > SE. When income effect is greater, and substitution effect is weak, then it is a Giffen good. [graph: indifference curves with a budget line shifting on Y-X axes, points a, b, c] SE < IE.