"In view of resource constraints and economic uncertainties in developing economies, the Hirschman's Model makes more sense." Discuss in the background of limitations of Balanced growth theory.
Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023
Hirschman propounded the Unbalanced Strategy of Development that needs lesser resources at one go. It uses the linkages between SOC & DPA for growth.
Unbalanced Growth
Assumptions 1. There are investment projects that appropriate more economies of scale than they create. They are called convergent series of investments or Directly Productive Activities (DPA) 2. Those projects that create more economies than they appropriate are called divergent series and Social Overhead Costs. Eg, Education, Infra.
Hirschman says that growth is a string of disequilibria which must not be culled, of which profits is a normal outcome.
Two Paths The economy can be disequilibriated through 2 paths:
1. SOC followed by DPA Govt. can invest large resources in education, infrastructure and skill training. This will reduce input costs of DPA and thus induce DPA for GDP growth. This path is smooth.
[graph: axes DPA cost (vertical) and SOC (horizontal); solid path AA'BB'C with points A, A', B, B', C, and three isoquants Q1, Q2, Q3 (Q3 > Q2 > Q1); Solid Path AA'BB'C is SOC followed by DPA]
2. DPA followed by SOC Initial investment in production will create demand for social overheads. The Government will be forced to invest in SOC to avoid price inflation. This is however dashed line AA''BB''C.
Benefits over Balanced 1. Resources needed are much less compared to Balanced strategy. 2. Unbalanced strategy uses Private enterprise economy and thus favours a more realistic mixed economy 3. Balanced growth requires an entrepreneurial state, which is a harsh demand.
Issues of Unbalanced Strategy 1. The shortages & bottlenecks created are beyond capacity of developing countries 2. Inflation control is difficult. 3. Business Entrepreneurs will react adversely, knowing that bottlenecks are deliberately created. 4. Govt may not follow up with SOC after initial DPA injection.
India failed in implementing this strategy during the 2nd FYP to 5th FYP, as it was unable to control consumption. With Inflation Targeting, it is now POSSIBLE.