How can the problem of Harrod's instability be solved?
Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023
Harrod's model is based on an unstable knife edge equilibrium, where the economy must run faster and faster to grow at a steady state.
Knife Edge Equilibrium 1. When Actual Growth (Ga) exceeds Warranted Growth (Gw), entrepreneurs are induced to invest more as profits are rising. Because investment will create more demand than supply, the equilibrium will further diverge.
[graph: Fig 1 - axes Growth (vertical) and Time (horizontal); curve Ga rising steeply, curve Gw rising more gently below it, diverging] [graph: Fig 2 - axes Growth (vertical) and Time (horizontal); curve Ga rising above curve Gw, both diverging further apart over time]
2. If Gw > Ga, entrepreneurs will reduce their investments. But because investment will lower supply by less than demand: DIVERGENCE
Reasons for Knife Edge 1. Rigidity of Interest rates, constant K/Y & K/L ratios. 2. Rigidity in wages & prices
How to Remove? 1. Kaldor's Solution When Gw > Ga, share of profits will reduce and Total Savings will reduce, as Sp > Sw. Thus savings will equal investment and Ga reduces to equal Gw.
2. Amartya Sen's Solution If prices and wages are only sticky and not rigid: A. If Ga > Gw => Prices increase -> Rental cost of Capital Decreases -> Gw decreases; Ga decreases B. If Gw > Ga => Wages lag Prices -> Real wage Rise -> Ga increases; Gw decreases