WTO has started losing its relevance, the result of which is protectionist tendencies across the world. Substantiate your arguments with proper reasons.
Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023
World Trade Organisation (WTO) is a global consensus based organisation promoting international trade. It has 164 members and has off-late started losing relevance.
Reasons for Loss of Effectiveness 1. Continuous dispute among Developed and Developing Nations:
A. On Agreement on Agriculture, developing countries are calling for a permanent solution to the issue of Public Stock holdings. For eg, India is asking for permission to export food from such stocks to food insecure nations.
B. TRIPS dispute: Developing countries are lobbying for less stringent IPR standards, specially for pharma. But developed nations are against it. For eg, the COVID-19 therapeutics waiver is inadequate.
C. TRIMS: The agreement is tilted heavily in favour of MNCs & developed countries and reduces policy space for developing nations.
2. Dysfunctional Dispute Appellate Body The heft of USA has rendered the appellate body dysfunctional, making WTO an ineffective institution.
3. COVID-19 crisis and the ensuing supply chain disruptions has forced countries to turn inwards and use protectionism for self reliance.
4. The Consensus: It delays decision making.
If WTO wants to make itself effective again, majority rule must replace consensus and developing countries be made more powerful.