Explain the concept of Optimum tariff in general equilibrium framework.
Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023
Optimum Tariff concept is a concept valid only for a Large country. This is because only a large country experiences a POSITIVE Terms of Trade Effect on imposing a tariff.
Optimum Tariff A tariff imposed has a negative wealth effect as trade goes down. The welfare lost is in the form of Consumption Distortion Loss, as consumers pay a higher price for imports, and Production Distortion Loss, as some inefficient domestic producers now start producing.
However, not the complete tariff is passed on to consumers and some is borne by foreign producers. This has a favourable ToT effect.
When a tariff is imposed for the first time, the ToT effect dominates the wealth effect and the country's welfare enhances.
As tariff is subsequently increased, a point is reached beyond which ToT effect < Wealth Effect.
At this point, ToT effect = Wealth Effect and the tariff is called OPTIMUM.
[graph: Fig 1 - axes Y and X; offer curves OC1 and OC2 from the origin; equilibrium E1, and E2 marked at a point of tangency where price ratio Px/Py = A, showing a lens-shaped area between two dashed curves]
[graph: Fig 2 - axes Y and X; offer curves OC1, OC2, OC'1, OC'2, OC''1, OC''2 from the origin, showing the curves shifting away and finally intersecting only at the origin]
In Fig 1, E2 is the point of optimal tariff where ToT effect = Wealth Effect.
However, if country 2 (the trading partner) retaliates, as its welfare is lowered by the tariff, offer curves subsequently shift away and finally intersect only at the Origin (OC'2, OC''1).
Therefore, optimum tariff is only applicable under the assumption of non-retaliation and a large country.