Topper Copies

In an open economy, with high capital mobility, fiscal management is as best as doing nothing. Do you agree?

Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023

The effectiveness of fiscal policy in an open economy with high capital mobility also depends upon the exchange rate system adopted by the economy.

Fixed Exchange Rates [graph: axes Interest Rates (vertical) and Output (horizontal); curves IS, LM, IS', BP intersecting; equilibrium E shifting to E0 as IS shifts right to IS', then LM shifts right to LM' reaching new equilibrium E1; dashed verticals at Y1 and Y2]

On an expansionary fiscal policy, IS shifts right towards IS'. The point E0 reached now is a Balance of Payment Surplus point, as for a given income, interest rates are higher => Capital Inflows.

To maintain the fixed exchange rate, the central bank will buy foreign currency and sell domestic currency. This will happen till LM shifts rightward to LM' to reach the new equilibrium E1.

The income has increased from Y1 to Y2 and thus fiscal policy is effective.

Flexible Exchange Rates [graph: axes Interest Rates (vertical) and Output Y (horizontal); curves IS, IS', IS'', LM, BP, BP'; equilibrium E shifting to E0 as IS shifts right to IS', then to E1 as IS falls back to IS'' and BP shifts to BP'; dashed verticals at Y1 and Y2]

On fiscal expansion and shift of IS rightwards from IS to IS', a point of BoP surplus => E0 is reached. The exchange rate will thus appreciate.

This will discourage exports & encourage imports. Thus NX will fall and both IS and BP will shift leftwards to reach E1.

At E1, income rises only a little, to Y2, while the exchange rate appreciates. Also, interest rates have risen to i2.

Fiscal Management is completely INEFFECTIVE only when PERFECT capital mobility along with a FLEXIBLE exchange rate system is present.