Topper Copies

"Trade is always growth promoting." Do you agree? Substantiate your arguments on the basis of established theories.

Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023

Trade impacts growth through the twin effect of 'Wealth Effect' and 'Terms of Trade' effect. The cumulative effect decides whether trade promotes growth or leads to immiserisation.

Wealth Effect Due to increase in exports, the exporting sector's income increases.

Terms of Trade Effect As quantity of exports rise, the relative prices of exports vis-a-vis imports fall.

Trade Promoting Growth When trade leads to an accumulation of the scarce factor of production, the terms of trade effect is favourable and trade is welfare enhancing, as shown in Fig 1 below.

[graph: axes Quantity of Y (vertical) and Quantity of X (horizontal); production possibility curve AA shifting outward to A'A'; equilibrium E1 on SIC1 at price ratio Px/Py = A; equilibrium E2 on SIC2 further out at price ratio Px/Py > A; labels X -> Labour Intensive, Y -> Capital Intensive]

As the production possibility function shifts outwards from AA to A'A' more on the Y axis than on the X axis, Terms of Trade for country A (labour surplus) improves. The new equilibrium point is now E2 on SIC2. It is clear that E2 lies to the North-East of E1 and therefore E2 > E1.

Ambiguous Case When the growth is export oriented, PPC shifts more on the X axis than on the Y axis. Wealth Effect is positive, but Terms of Trade Effect is negative.

If ToT effect < Wealth Effect, trade is growth enhancing, as in Fig 2.

[graph: Fig 2 - axes Qy (vertical) and Qx (horizontal); PPC AA shifting to A'A' more on the X axis; equilibrium E1 on SIC1, new equilibrium E2 on SIC2 further out]

Bhagwati's Immiserising Growth Bhagwati asserted that the Terms of Trade effect for a developing country is much higher and unfavourable, as shown in Fig 3. The overall impact is IMMISERISATION as SIC2 < SIC1.

[graph: Fig 3 - axes Quantity of Y (vertical) and Qx (horizontal); PPC A-A1 shifting to A'-A2 far out on the X axis; equilibrium E1 on SIC1, new equilibrium E2 on a smaller SIC2 closer in, showing immiserising growth]

E2 was available to country A earlier as well, but it chose E1 => E1 < E2.

A country which is largely dependent on exports, whose exports are price inelastic, is more prone to face immisserisation due to trade.