Topper Copies

How can a mutually beneficial trade between two nations be explained in case of increasing returns to scale, assuming the two nations are identical in every respect?

Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023

Lyndall gave a model for mutually beneficial trade under increasing returns to scale based on COMPLETE SPECIALISATION.

Assumptions 1. Two countries A & B 2. Concave PPCs which are identical, as increasing returns to scale 3. Identical preferences => same SICs

Model [graph: axes Quantity of Y (vertical) and Quantity of X (horizontal); a concave production possibility curve from A to B; point E1 on SIC1 near A, point E2 on SIC2 nearer B]

Initially in no trade condition, both countries are at E1 on SIC1. As trade opens up, one country starts specialising in X and the other starts specialising in Y. Both finally reach E2 on SIC2.

Clearly SIC2 > SIC1 & E2 > E1. Therefore, trade is mutually beneficial.

Inferences 1. Any country can specialise in any commodity, based on domestic market size for the respective commodity. 2. It explains intra-industry trade, which is very prevalent in today's world: India exporting hatchbacks while importing sedans.

Criticisms 1. Two countries can't have identical PPCs & resource endowments. 2. Increasing returns to scale are not observed without large markets.

Mutually beneficial trade is therefore possible under increasing returns.