Topper Copies

Examine why classical theory couldn't explain paradox of thrift? What were the different assumptions under Keynes that it could be explained? What was its role in explaining great depression.

Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023

Paradox of Thrift is the macroeconomic scenario where the collective will of people to save more, for a rainy day, results in a lowering of income & no change in Income.

Keynesian explanation Assumptions 1. Investment is totally autonomous and depends on animal spirits. 2. Income is demand determined, as the economy is assumed to be below full employment output. 3. Savings & Consumption are functions of Income only.

Explanation: An increase in the Marginal Propensity to Save will rotate & shift the savings schedule anticlockwise, as shown below.

[a diagram: Savings/Investment axis vs Income, showing S1 and S2 savings curves and an I1 investment line, with Y1 and Y2 marked on the income axis]

Because Investment is fixed at I1, and in equilibrium I=S, the increase in MPS will keep total savings constant at I1.

Classical view The Classical Economists saw both savings & investment as depending on interest rates. According to them, as savings increase due to an autonomous shock, interest rates will fall & Investments will increase to equate Savings & Investment. This is shown in the figures below, in both the Classical & Keynesian Models.

[two diagrams: the first plots Savings/Investment against Income, showing investment lines I2 and I1 with a savings curve and Y1 marked; the second plots Interest Rate against Savings/Investment, showing S1 and S2 curves and an investment curve, with i1=S1 and i2=S2 marked]

Therefore Incomes remain unchanged at Y1, as the Investment schedule shifts up.

Explaining the Great Depression During the Great Depression in the 1930's, people wanted to save more for a rainy day. This increased their marginal propensity to save, and low animal spirits caused Incomes to fall, while savings either fell or remained constant.

To get out of the Paradox, Keynes suggested Government Expenditure, as it is not dependent on animal spirits. It will shift the Investment schedule up and revive the economy.