Does government borrowing always crowd out private investments? Analyse.
Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023
In the neo-Keynesian IS-LM framework, an increase in Government Expenditure leads to an increase in interest rates, which might or might not lead to crowding out.
Crowding out In the Classical Macroeconomic framework, and its Loanable Funds Theory, Savings act as the supply of funds, while Investment & Government Borrowing act as the supply of bonds. Savings vary positively with interest rates, while Investments vary negatively.
An increase in Government Borrowing will increase interest rates from i1 to i2 and crowd out Private investment = I1-I2.
[a diagram: Interest Rate axis vs Investment/Savings, showing the Government Borrowing curve, a Savings curve and an I=S curve, with i1 and i2 marked, and I2, I1 marked on the horizontal axis]
Ways to avoid crowding out 1. If LM is horizontal, as in Neo-Keynesian analysis, there will be no crowding out of private investment, as interest rates don't increase. [two diagrams: one showing a horizontal LM curve against Output, one showing an investment curve against the interest rate] 2. If the government borrowings are used to provide investment subsidies, Autonomous Investment rises & there is no crowding out. 3. If the Government uses borrowing to pay back existing debt, then also crowding out is curtailed.
The amount & direction of crowding out on government borrowing depends on the use of the proceeds. CAPEX is thus desirable.