What is the role of low interest sensitivity of investment in determining effectiveness of monetary and fiscal policy?
Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023
A low interest sensitivity of Investment, as during the depression phase, means a steeper IS schedule. This implies FISCAL POLICY is more effective than MONETARY.
Slope of IS The IS schedule defines product market equilibrium, where Savings equal Investment. If Investments are less sensitive to interest rates, an increase in Income leading to an increase in Savings will need a higher reduction in interest rates. Thus the IS curve will be steep.
Monetary policy An increase in money supply shifts LM to LM2 towards the right and reduces interest rates from r1 to r2.
[a diagram: interest rate axis vs Output, showing the IS curve and LM1, LM2 curves, with r1 and r2 marked]
However, investment doesn't increase much, and therefore incomes are raised by less, to Y2 from Y1.
Fiscal policy As Government Expenditure rises, IS shifts rightward. However, interest rates rise by very little, to i2, and thus there is very little crowding out. This ensures a high impact on Output, from Y1 to Y2.
[a diagram: interest rate axis vs Output, showing IS and LM curves intersecting, with ie and i1 marked on the interest axis and Y1, Y2 marked on the output axis]
The conclusion is important for COVID-19 times, where fiscal policy will be much more effective than monetary policy. However, the centre is doing just the opposite.