"Monetarists and Classicals draw same conclusions in both short run as well as long run." Analyse.
Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023
While Monetarists believe that only money matters, Classicals believe in Dichotomy of Money, where money has no effect whatsoever on Output.
Monetarists For monetarists, private sector AD is stable and money velocity is also stable. They used the Cambridge Quantity Theory of Money, Md = k x PY, and defined 'k' explicitly to depend on returns on equity, bonds, money, wealth, and institutional factors. Thus PY = Ms/k. As Ms is exogenously fixed, it is an Income Equation. Thus Money Supply can determine and change Nominal Income. In the short run, Prices are less flexible, and thus the change is in REAL OUTPUT. In the long run, Prices adjust and Real Output returns to original.
Classicals For Classicals, real output was totally determined by supply factors, and AD depended solely on money supply: P x Yd = Ms x V (Money velocity). The money supply thus had no impact on output, even in the SHORT RUN.
Therefore, Monetarists & Classicals gave the same conclusions in the Long Run but differed in the SHORT RUN.