Is it always true that direct subsidy makes an individual better off than indirect subsidy of the same amount?
Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023
The net gain in welfare on account of a subsidy also depends on the nature of commodities. In case of a Giffen Good, for which Income Effect > Substitution Effect, Indirect Subsidy can be better than Direct Subsidy.
Normal goods [a diagram: indifference curves and budget lines on money vs quantity of X axes, budget lines M1 and M, indifference curves IC1, IC2, IC3 with IC3>IC2>IC1, points E1 and E2 marked]
As a result of an indirect subsidy, the budget line shifts from MX1 to MX2 and Equilibrium moves from E1 on IC1 to E2 on IC2. An equal direct subsidy of M1M2 will create a new equilibrium at E3 on IC3. IC3 > IC2 because the IC is tangent to the new budget line in the portion above E2, as the lower portion was also available earlier but not preferred.
Giffen goods In the case of Giffen goods, an increase in income leads the consumer to buy less of the commodity, and there might come a scenario where an Indirect subsidy is better.
[a diagram: indifference curves and budget lines on money income vs quantity of X axes, budget lines M2 and M1, indifference curves IC1, IC2, IC3, points E1 and E2 marked]
In this case IC2 < IC3, as Income Effect > Substitution Effect.
Other benefits of indirect tax 1. The analysis that direct taxes are better than indirect taxes assumes that people understand what is best for themselves. Eg, Alcohol. 2. The aim of a subsidy might be to encourage consumption of a particular commodity. Eg, Millets.
Therefore, the desirability of the type of subsidy will depend on the goal of the subsidy as well as the nature of the commodity for which it is used.