"The Keynesian view on role of saving didn't match the classical idea". Discuss.
Nesrin P Fasim, AIR 703, 2024
The Keynesian view on savings differs from classical idea on the basis of explanation that Classicals said that an increase in savings can improve output in the economy whereas for Keynes, it will result in decrease in output - called Paradox of thrift.
Classical case:
[diagram: three stacked graphs; top, interest rate against investment with the supply of loanable funds shifting right (supply increased) crossing the demand for loanable funds, interest rates i1 and i2, investment I1 and I2; middle, output against labour with production functions Y=f(L1) and Y=f(L2), labour L1 and L2; bottom, price against output with an AD curve, prices P1 and P2, output Y1 and Y2]
This is because as savings↑ -> capital stock↑ -> Marginal product of labour increases -> production function becomes steep and shifts upwards -> labour productivity↑ -> Aggregate supply↑ and output increases.
Keynesian idea of savings: According to Keynes, Income = Consumption + savings Y = C + S S = Y - C where C = C̅ + cY S = Y - C̅ - cY => S = -C̅ + Y(1-c)
Also investment is not a function of interest rate, but due to animal spirits, where investment is due to behaviour of bulls & bears in the stock market.
[diagram: savings-investment graph with S1 = -C̅+Y(1-c) shifting left to S2 = -C̅+Y(1-c), crossing a flat I=I̅ line at points E1 and E2, output Y1 and Y2 marked]
The figure shows that as savings increased from S1 to S2, the curve shifts to left as a result, the output has decreased.
This explains Keynesian idea of paradox of thrift thus do not match with Classicals who believed that an increase in savings always resulted in the increase on output.
This is due to the fact that Keynes relied on autonomous investment function wherein the interest rate doesn't affect investment. It is the behaviour of bond holders that affect the savings and hence the output.